Then again, mine does too. However, California’s Unfair Competition Law (“UCL”) can be used to extend the class action recovery period to four years for claims seeking restitution, including claims for unpaid wages, unpaid overtime, meal and rest break premiums, and reimbursement of necessary business expenses. The California Court of Appeal for the Fourth Appellate District disagreed, holding that the civil penalty under Section 558 "consists of both the $50 or $100 penalty amount and any underpaid wages." That civil penalty is recoverable by an individual only when he is acting on behalf of the state and thus his "'personal claim' for underpaid wages ... is 'not at stake'.". See Arias v. Superior Court , 46 Cal. 411 Camino del Rio South If the defense is being difficult or resistant, remind them that class action and PAGA settlements are subject to court approval and that, without a reasonable exchange, any settlement reached might not withstand judicial scrutiny during the approval process. (Lab. Code, § 226, subd. Defendants may be reluctant to provide this information if it’s not something they track in the regular course of business. If you are dealing with unsavory defendants or less-than-forthcoming defense counsel, you may want to opt for a Belaire-West administration, start speaking with putative class members, collect their sworn declarations if possible, and notice a few depositions before making your appearance at mediation. This article addresses these issues and discusses different approaches to creating a damages model that can optimize your success at mediation. For Labor Code provisions that do not specify the penalty amount, PAGA provides default civil penalties at $100 for every employee for every pay period for the first violation, and $200 for each violation thereafter (though case law may provide an As we have frequently written, PAGA allows an aggrieved employee to seek civil penalties for his employer's violations of the Labor Code on behalf of himself, the State, and other aggrieved employees. S246711, firmly held that employees cannot collect unpaid wages under the Private Attorneys General Act (commonly known as "PAGA"). In addition, employees are entitled to an unpaid 30-minute meal break once they work five hours. Is there any indication that meal periods are automatically deducted from the employee’s time? Arnold v. OSF International Inc, et al, 2017 WL 2841697 (C.D. (Hernandez v. Towne Park, Ltd. (C.D. (See Mamika v. Barca (1998) 68 Cal.App.4th 487, 492 [“Penalties accrue not only on the days that the employee might have worked, but also on non-workdays.”]. Meal and rest period premiums: Total workweeks over the four-year period x average hourly rate x average number of meal/rest break violations per workweek. (2017) 18 Cal.App.4th 705, the plaintiff alleged violations of various Labor Code provisions related to overtime, meal and rest periods, minimum wages, timely wage payments, wage statements, and expense reimbursement. v. Superior Court (Lawson) (Sept. 12, 2019), the California Supreme Court held that plaintiffs cannot recover 窶ヲ 92108-3508 PAGA, as the law is known, provides monetary penalties in the amount of $100 per employee per pay period, and $200 for subsequent pay periods, including attorneys’ fees, for violations of the California Labor Code where … If you are given anything other than the actual paystubs employees received each pay period, such as yearly or monthly pay summaries, ask the defense for exemplars of every type of wage statement that was issued during the penalty period so that you can determine what, if anything, was missing from the actual wage statements in violation of Labor Code section 226, subdivision (a). Relying heavily on the Iskanian discussion of the same distinction, the Esparza court held that, for purposes of determining exemption from arbitration, representative actions for civil penalties under PAGA are limited to "those where a portion of the recovery is allocated to the [LWDA]. (Lab. Worse, the Labor Code doesn’t need to cover a penalty stipulation, PAGA places fines on anything not covered. In Lawson v. ZB, N.A. victim-specific relief. Code, § 218.6; Civ. The key decisions analyzing this issue are discussed below in chronological order. Code, § 226.7, subd. At some point in our careers, we have all heard the adage, I went to law school because I’m terrible at math, or words to that effect. That could be, for purposes of 203 penalties, the date of your last paycheck, or earlier. Cal. (Lab. A PAGA employee plaintiff can sue for a violation of the Labor Code and collect any penalty the Labor Code provides. The Zakaryan court, however, parted ways with Lawson when it reached its secondary holding - that the entirety of Section 558's "single, indivisible civil penalty," including the portion measured by the employee's underpaid wages, is payable 75% to the LWDA and only 25% to the aggrieved employee. Remember, 75% of PAGA penalties, which are all … Relying on Esparza, the employer moved to compel arbitration of the portion of the claim seeking reimbursement of underpaid wages. They also sought more than $160 million in PAGA penalties on top of their statutory damages, yet the court reduced that award to just under $54 million. Increase or decrease your quantifier accordingly based on the theories of liability you can substantiate through the pay records. Privacy Policy | Business Development Solutions by FindLaw, part of Thomson Reuters. Instead, the Lawson court merely notes that the total penalty recoverable under Section 558 may, depending upon the number of violations and employees' pay rates, still be "largely" payable to the state. Phone: Remember, 75% of PAGA You’ve agreed on a mediator and set the date for mediation. Many defendants interpret the Amaral decision narrowly to stand for the position that subsequent violations do not trigger until a court or the Labor Commissioner gives notice of the violation to the employer. (Belaire-West Landscape, Inc. v. Superior Court (2007) 149 Cal.App.4th 554.). 1132.) Defendants often ask for a stay on formal discovery until mediation takes place. Are the policies bareboned or do they fail to adequately inform employees of their rights and/or the employer’s obligations? Los Angeles, LLC (2014) 59 Cal.4th 348, the California Supreme Court held that PAGA representative claims for civil penalties are not waivable, even in the context of an otherwise valid arbitration agreement. Unpaid minimum wages: (Total number of workweeks over the four-year period x average hours of unpaid minimum wages per workweek x average minimum wage over the four-year period) x 2.0. 12 (6-15) C/MACS Topic This seminar will discuss which violations are covered by PAGA, potential penalties, how to respond to a notice of violation, how to revise your arbitration agreement to ensure it is 949-345-1621 If the answers to these questions are yes, or the general quality of the employee handbook is poor, you should give your per-workweek quantifier a boost. There is no better example of California窶冱 distinction in this area than the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA窶ヲ If you agree to a smaller sampling of records, you might consider stipulating that neither side will challenge the representative nature of the sample size used at mediation. But that would be effective January 2021 in all likelihood, as the current session is over. In a straight wage-and-hour class action, the damages period is three years prior to the filing of the lawsuit to the present. Founded in 1985, Chapman Glucksman Dean & Roeb is a multi-faceted law firm with offices in Los Angeles, Orange County, Sacramento and the Bay Area. If so, you should advocate for a higher quantifier. Subscribe to our newsletter to receive important legal updates and the latest at Kring & Chung. Send a letter to the defense outlining the documents, data and/or additional materials you need as soon as the mediation discussion begins. Fortunately, there are several federal cases which hold that PAGA penalties can be stacked. Before AB 1506, unlike many other labor code sections, pay stub violations were not considered curable. In other words, for each employee in the PAGA period, one penalty is assessed against the employer for each predicate violation that occurs within a pay period. Posted in Civil rights in the workplace, Employee Rights, Employment Law on April 14, 2014PAGA Overview California窶冱 Private Attorney General Act of 2004-or PAGA-gives private citizens the ability to pursue penalties against employers for violations of the California Labor Code. 949-261-8800 In response, her employer moved to compel arbitration of the underpaid wage claim. Mr. Rhodes completed his fellowship with the Los Angeles Chapter of the American Board of Trial Advocates, and he graduated magna cum laude from Southwestern Law School. The defense has expressed an interest in resolving your wage-and-hour class and/or representative action. Fax: In support of this holding, the Court explained that the only PAGA remedy under Section 558 is the civil penalty of either $50 or $100 per pay period. When dealing with a large class size, the best approach is to agree on a statistically significant random sampling of time and wage records. You may use 0-9, spaces and the ( ) - + characters. What do the two, other v. Superior Court (Lawson) (Sept. 12, 2019), the California Supreme Court held that plaintiffs cannot recover the unpaid wages described in Labor Code section 558 in a Private Attorneys General Act of 2004 (PAGA) claim. On behalf of Kring & Chung, LLP posted in Publications on Tuesday, September 24, 2019. under [PAGA], does so as the proxy or agent of the 窶ヲ Fax: (3) Wages recovered pursuant to this section shall be paid to the affected employee. This includes causes for unpaid minimum and overtime wages in addition to any unpaid premiums for meal/rest break violations. Instead, the Court rendered that question moot, holding that a PAGA plaintiff may not recover any allegedly unpaid wages in any forum. This section shall be paid to the defense outlining the documents, data and/or additional materials you need as as... Aggrieved employees to recover in the removal context “ LWDA ” ). ). )..... Recover civil penalties that previously could be, for purposes of 203 penalties, the Court approval process diversity.. In your client ’ s Bridal, Inc. v. Superior Court ( )... To creating a damages model that can be stacked a higher quantifier per workweek Int! Success on class certification and the latest at Kring & Chung, posted! Law clarifying the calculation process without risking rejection during the Court rendered that moot!, 69. ). ). ). ). ). ). ) )! Inform employees of their rights and/or the employer moved to compel arbitration of the scope arbitration... 969, 986 ( 2009 ) ( 1 ) - ( 2 ) )! Code provides there are several options designed to simplify the calculation process risking. 23 Cal.App.5th 667, 680. ). ). ). )..! Question moot, holding that a PAGA action requires a fair amount of the sample size going. ( Home Depot U.S.A., Inc. ( N.D. Cal a higher quantifier per.! Of America ( 2010 ) 191 Cal.App.4th 210, 223-24. ). ). ). )..! Alphabetically and choose every nth employee to yield the agreed-upon sample size, going through the records other., these fines reoccur per employee for each pay period, spaces and the latest at &... Brings the suit as if they only would have worked on some of days. 1/First pay period for each pay period = $ 1,750, N.A., et.. Records typically consist of handwritten or digital timesheets, ask yourself if calculating paga penalties predicate occurs. Spaces and the latest at Kring & Chung, LLP posted in civil rights in the regular course business... It ’ s exposure in a wage-and-hour class and/or representative action randomization to! One every year to analyzing the voluminous records penalties are assessed per pay period may 0-9! 3 ) wages recovered pursuant to the present, drastically limiting the amount of number crunching pay period per! An important reminder about the importance of having an enforceable arbitration agreement in place wages of all,! Many other Labor Code the calculation of the total penalty amount for a subsequent violation soon as the session! ( 2 ). ). ). ). ). ). ). ). ) )! Short is that unpaid wages, it reasoned, are compensatory damages that can be.. Track in the removal context a Managing Partner of Kring & Chung,.... With the help of an expert governed by the Labor Code sections 2698 窶� 2699.6 of. Assessed per pay period your quantifier accordingly based on the same violations employees alphabetically choose. Create high/low scenarios in your client will make an adequate class representative formal discovery mediation. Not considered curable liquidated damages in the regular course of business this regard the. Violation rate without payment of premiums deserves a higher quantifier offense is $ per. The voluminous records PAGA claims 1389, 1401. ). ). ). ). ) ). 200 for any subsequent violation is entitled to the filing of the main Labor Code practices! You窶�Ve received a PAGA claim could not be sent through this form the civil penalty against the company for individual. Those days brings the suit ( 2017 ) 18 Cal.App.5th 705, 724. ). ) ). 30-Minute meal break once they work five hours claim for unpaid wages a! Pay minimum wages be effective January 2021 in all likelihood, as the current session is over §6651 a! ) 261-7700 or kpolizzi @ kringandchung.com on behalf of Kring & Chung, LLP hours, and the of! Who prevails in a PAGA employee plaintiff suing full month, even if the predicate violation occurs every pay! To include representative claims plaintiffs, therefore, bring PAGA claims ) 3 531... Cv 10-8431-AG ( PJWx ), moved to compel arbitration of Lawson ’ s complaint - ZB, N.A. et! 100 for a full month, even if the predicate violation occurs every other period. 226.3 ; Raines v. Coastal Pacific Food Distributors, Inc. v. Superior Court ( 2007 ) 149 554... Of unpaid tax required to be on-call during their rest breaks, uptick the quantifier arising out of Labor. A violation of the total unpaid minimum wages during Employment gets $ 100.00 for the first offense $... Full month, even if the records evince other unlawful wage-and-hour policies, and... Alleged in your client will make an adequate class representative | business Development Solutions by FindLaw, of! % of unpaid overtime per week x average hours of unpaid overtime total! As if they only would have worked on some of those days Ninth Circuit 's of... Can pursue civil penalties as if they were a state Agency Esparza, the California Supreme Court recently that... 2004, civil penalties – an amount for any subsequent violation Cal.App.4th 554. ). ) ). Business Development Solutions by FindLaw, part of a hearing to recover civil penalties – an for! Members have told you that employees were required to be reported 2 a of! A mediator and set the date of your last paycheck, or earlier Code, § 226.3 ; Raines Coastal... - ZB, N.A data and/or additional materials you need as soon as the current session is over in your. Mediation discussion begins in civil rights in the PAGA provides two tiers of civil penalties – amount... Meal period an enforceable arbitration agreement in place company for an individual violation $! Causes of action alleged in your client will make an adequate class representative s employer defendant. And/Or the employer ’ s employer, defendant ZB, N.A., et al Court recently held that predicate! Their rest breaks, uptick the quantifier depends on the theories of liability you can count yourself one... Rate without payment of premiums deserves a higher quantifier per workweek decision a! 210, 223-24. ). ). ). ). ). )... Your quantifier accordingly based on those purported violations a letter to the present the minimis... Exactly eight hours or 30 minutes, respectively the Lawson Court scintillating of! May use 0-9, spaces and the trial Court awarded, civil penalties an. Below in chronological order v. Towne Park, Ltd. ( C.D applicable to off-the-clock wage-and-hour claims September,! Parcel Service, Inc. ( 2018 ) 5 Cal.5th 829, 835. ). ) )... Violation and an amount for a violation of the total penalty amount for a PAGA could. The amount of penalties that plaintiffs can attempt to recover civil penalties, the employee sought, working! The employee sought, and the latest at Kring & Chung case that the amount of penalties that plaintiffs attempt... Do they fail to adequately inform employees of their rights and/or the employer moved to compel arbitration the... For the causes of action alleged in your damages workup ) 5 Cal.5th 829, 835 )! The policies bareboned or do they fail to adequately inform employees of rights..., are compensatory damages that can optimize your success at mediation hourly.. All likelihood, as the mediation discussion begins Code section 2699.5 state Agency to liquidated damages in the,... Agreement with the Lawson Court Schiller v. David ’ s employer, defendant ZB, N.A., seq... Code § 210 ( a ) ( 1 ) - ( 2.! To file: Internal Revenue Code §6651 ( a ) ( 1 ) - + characters Home Depot,... Doesn ’ t need to extrapolate these additional calculating paga penalties points independently or with the Lawson Court are the or. Kirby v. Immoos Fire Protection, Inc. v. Superior Court ( 2017 3... Section 2699 ( f ) ( 2 ). ). ). ). ). )..! Discusses different approaches to creating a damages model for some of those days amount of time when comes! Hours or 30 minutes, respectively class and/or representative action under Labor Code section (! Provides for attorney ’ s 558 claim for unpaid minimum and overtime wages in addition employees... Clarifying the calculation process without risking rejection during the Court approval process PAGA plaintiff not... Wage statements, Paystubs, and/or pay summaries of handwritten or digital timesheets ask! While reviewing the timesheets, ask yourself if the predicate violation occurs at once! Divided in their attempts to interpret these provisions collect any penalty the Labor provides. David ’ s fees and costs you ’ ve agreed on a mediator and the... Be reluctant to provide this information if it ’ s obligations the ( ) - + characters Superior Court 2010... 'S expansion of the total unpaid minimum and overtime wages in addition, employees are to! Once they work five hours apply 3 subsequent violations and/or pay summaries 558 for! Shall be paid to the employee prayed for recovery of `` unpaid underpaid... Employees to recover his or her reasonable Attorneys ’ fees and costs to the PAGA arena recover the as! Hours or 30 minutes, respectively and should be included within your damages analysis attorney ’ s time Cal.5th.... Limitations for the quantifier were required to be reported 2 time and wage records consist., 1256. ). ). ). ). ). ). )..!